Learn
A little clarity for your next decision.
Loading your learning library…
Investor WorkspaceWelcome, there!Log Out
Investor WorkspaceA little clarity for your next decision.
By Jerry Baker
A Kentucky 1031 exchange can defer federal tax on gain from the sale of qualifying business or investment real estate when you buy qualifying replacement property. The next purchase still needs a review of state and local taxes, rental rules, land rights, and repair costs. I would compare direct property with a qualifying Delaware Statutory Trust interest based on the income you need and the duties you want to keep.
An owner selling a small apartment building may want fewer late-night calls. A family selling a farm may need a way to divide responsibilities. Someone selling a leased warehouse may want less exposure to one tenant.
Those are different problems. I would not start all three conversations with the same list of investments. First, decide what you need from the sale and what the next investment must do for you.
Write down your annual income need, the cash you need to keep available, and the time you are willing to spend on property decisions. Include a less pleasant year in that plan. A budget should allow for a tenant leaving or a major repair, not just rent checks arriving on time.
Ask family members who will share the result what they want, too. An heir may value the land but have little interest in running the business on it. A spouse may want to keep owning real estate without managing workers, leases, and repairs. The ownership plan should account for those differences.
Section 1031 generally applies to real property held for investment or business. It does not cover a personal residence used only as your home or property held mainly for sale. Qualifying U.S. real estate can generally replace qualifying U.S. real estate in another state. Cash or other nonqualifying value received may create taxable gain even when part of a transaction qualifies. [1]
A typical delayed exchange requires written identification of replacement property within 45 days after the sale. Completion is generally due within 180 days or the federal return's due date, including extensions, if sooner. The rules also control identification limits and access to the proceeds. Arrange the qualified intermediary before closing so the sale funds are handled properly. [2]
I would build a short list of tasks with the intermediary, CPA, attorney, and closing team. Assign dates for the tax estimate, title review, inspection, financing, and document review. A lender's target date is not a substitute for an exchange deadline.
Separate equity, debt, and tax basis. Equity is not the same as gain, and loan payoff is not the same as basis. Ask your CPA to work from the tax records and closing figures, including prior exchanges and depreciation where relevant.
Do this before a buyer creates time pressure. An exchange can be useful, but it should not push you into a replacement that you would reject if you had more time.
Kentucky's Department of Revenue states that the individual and fiduciary income-tax rate is 3.5% for 2026. It lists 4% for 2024 and 2025. Apply the correct year's rules to taxable income, not the gross property price. A headline rate does not calculate your gain or settle how an exchange will be reported. [3]
Ask your CPA for a comparison of a taxable sale and the proposed exchange. Include federal tax, Kentucky tax, any entity-level tax, and tax in another state if relevant. The ownership entity and the owners' home states can affect that review.
Local taxes need a separate check. Kentucky DOR says it does not administer local occupational, net-profits, or gross-receipts taxes and directs taxpayers to the appropriate local officials. Have the CPA check whether your rental or business activity falls within those rules in the city or county involved. [4]
I would ask for the expected filing duties as well as the estimated dollars. Who files after the sale? Is a local account being closed or updated? Does the new property create another return? These are easier questions to resolve while the records are in front of everyone.
Do not assume a federal exchange answer erases all closing costs or all local tax duties. Make the cash plan from the amounts the closing team expects to use, and confirm the final tax treatment with your advisers.
Kentucky real property is assessed by a local property valuation administrator, or PVA. DOR explains that the general standard is estimated fair cash value, while qualifying farm land may use agricultural value. When an assessment increases, the notice explains the review period. The appeal process starts with a conference with the PVA during that period. [5]
For a purchase, request the current assessment, tax bills, property description, and any special treatment. Compare the recorded building area and use with what you see on site. A converted space or new structure may change the picture.
I would also ask the PVA what facts could change the assessment after this sale. Do not treat the seller's bill as a price quote for your ownership. A farm-use assessment or owner-specific benefit should not be carried into your budget without review.
Use a simple sensitivity check. If you estimated $5,000 in annual property tax but the supported figure is $7,400, that is $2,400 less cash each year, or $200 a month. These are invented numbers, not a Kentucky tax-rate estimate. They show why the right expense matters.
Keep the notice dates on your calendar. If you later disagree with an assessment, gather evidence and follow the stated process. Waiting until a bill is due may leave less room to address the value used to calculate it.
Kentucky's current agricultural application describes qualifying farm tracts generally as at least ten contiguous acres in the specified production uses, with separate paths for aquaculture and certain government programs. Horticultural land generally needs at least five contiguous acres of qualifying commercial use. The owner's homesite acreage is excluded from the required use acreage. The application states that it remains valid until ownership transfers or land use changes. [6]
Ask the PVA to review the exact tract. “Ten acres with a house” does not establish that ten acres meet the farm-use test. Bring the parcel map, current lease, description of activity, and other records the office requests.
If you are buying a horse farm, separate the land investment from the operating business. Who owns the horses, equipment, feed, and movable items? Is the tenant paying rent for land and buildings, or are you expected to provide boarding and care?
I would read the lease for fence work, pasture care, manure removal, utilities, barns, and insurance. A high rent can look less attractive if it leaves the owner with large costs that were not shown in the forecast.
Also ask what happens when the tenant leaves. Could the next user operate with the same layout? Would stalls, buildings, and access serve another tenant? A specialized property needs a realistic next-user plan, especially if one operator provides most of the income.
Lexington's Purchase of Development Rights program uses conservation easements to preserve participating farms. Owners keep the land while development rights are restricted. The city says its PVA records flag participation and recorded easements can be obtained from the county clerk. It also requires approval for new or expanded housing and paving on PDR farms; some other work depends on the easement's terms. [7]
I would obtain the actual recorded easement, not stop at a map or the seller's description. Ask counsel to explain the rules for housing, farm structures, division of the property, and changes in use. Identify the parties who must approve a project.
An easement may be consistent with a long-term farming plan. It may conflict with a plan to sell home sites later. Price the rights you are buying, not rights that a former owner already gave up.
Consider a buyer who expects rent from a farm today and a development sale later. If the recorded restrictions do not permit the later use, the investment needs to work without that assumed exit. I would recalculate the return before trying to explain away the document.
Tax status, zoning, and an easement are separate layers. A favorable answer on one does not answer the other two. Keep each approval and restriction in the file so the business plan is tied to the actual rights.
Kentucky law authorizes local governments to adopt the Uniform Residential Landlord and Tenant Act in its entirety. It is not sound to assume that every property in the state operates under the same adopted framework. Have Kentucky counsel identify the applicable state and local rules for the address and lease. [8]
For occupied property, ask for signed leases, addenda, deposit records, open repair requests, notices, and any side agreements. Compare the rent roll with actual collections. Ask why a tenant's balance is overdue instead of simply assuming it will be paid after closing.
Inspect the systems that affect daily life: heat, water, power, doors, stairs, and drainage. Then match the findings to the repair budget. A seller's recent cosmetic work should not distract from an older roof or unresolved moisture problem.
The closing plan should state who transfers deposits, sends notices, handles pending work, and holds the tenant records. Give the new manager a complete file. A change in ownership is an especially poor time to lose track of a promise already made to a tenant.
Louisville Metro requires covered long-term rental properties to be registered under its rental-registry rules. Its guidance also lists exemptions that need to be checked for the specific property. Registration does not replace the property-maintenance code. The city provides a public search for registered rentals. [9]
Request the registration record, any inspection findings, and the status of open violations. Confirm who is listed as the responsible owner and manager. A property that appears in the registry still needs a physical and legal review.
I would ask the seller to explain unresolved notices before setting the repair allowance. A notice may concern one unit, a shared area, or a building system. The cost depends on the scope and the required solution, not just the number of notices.
Put ownership and contact updates on the handoff list. Confirm renewal and fee requirements with the city. A manager should know how to receive and respond to a notice even if the owner lives in another state.
Lexington begins its short-term rental process with zoning verification. The city distinguishes hosted rentals, where a primary resident continues to occupy the property, from unhosted rentals. A purchase intended for full-time guest use should be reviewed under the actual operating plan, not the seller's different living arrangement. [10]
The city's adopted rural rules call for a conditional-use permit and health-department review of septic capacity. The published summary generally allows hosted rentals, with limited exceptions for unhosted use, and includes occupancy and spacing requirements. Ask planning staff to apply the current ordinance to the parcel. A farm address does not automatically allow a guest-rental business. [11]
I would request the zoning decision, conditions, rental license, occupancy records, and any complaint history. Check whether a sale or change in operator affects the approvals. Ask about parking, access, septic capacity, and the use of outbuildings before counting additional bedrooms.
Review income month by month. Event dates may support strong weekends while other periods are quieter. Use actual receipts, refunds, blocked dates, and expenses to understand the year. Do not multiply a high nightly rate by every night on the calendar.
Separate taxes collected for government agencies from owner revenue. Then subtract platform charges, cleaning, management, utilities, insurance, upkeep, and reserves. If the property needs hands-on service to earn its income, include the cost of that work even if the seller did it for free.
The Kentucky Geological Survey provides maps for karst potential, sinkholes, landslides, groundwater, and other features. Its karst layer describes the tendency of rock units to have features such as sinkholes, caves, and springs. These maps help frame questions; they do not provide a site-specific engineering conclusion about a building or proposed project. [12]
I would give relevant maps and repair history to a qualified engineer or geologist when site conditions warrant it. Ask what inspections or tests are needed, what they can establish, and what remains uncertain. Do not turn “nothing marked on the map” into a guarantee.
The state's Mine Map Information Center also maintains coal and clay mine records and offers access through its mapping system. Its history notes that a 1948 fire destroyed many old maps, though some have since been replaced. A record search should be part of the review where mining history is relevant. [13]
Ask counsel about mineral rights, access rights, and recorded restrictions. Ask the engineer about the site's physical condition. Those are related reviews, but a title search does not test soil or rock, and an engineer does not decide what rights the deed conveys.
If a proposed addition, road, or building depends on expensive site work, put the estimate in the budget now. A parcel can be large and still offer a limited area for a practical project.
Here is a fictional direct-property example. Annual rent is $60,000. Vacancy and unpaid rent reduce collections by $4,000. Operating costs total $19,000, debt service is $17,000, and the owner sets aside $5,000 for future major repairs.
That leaves $15,000 before income taxes: $60,000 minus $4,000, $19,000, $17,000, and $5,000. If the cash invested is $300,000, the illustrated cash yield is 5%. These figures are not market estimates or a forecast.
Now test a harder year. If collections are $6,000 lower and operating costs are $2,000 higher, cash falls to $7,000 before income taxes. A property that seemed to provide $1,250 a month now provides about $583. Ask whether the household budget can handle that range.
Use the same cost categories when reviewing other options. A quoted return that leaves out major repairs should not be compared directly with one that funds them. Debt principal payments also affect cash, even though tax accounting treats them differently from interest.
IRS Revenue Ruling 2004-86 describes a specific DST structure whose interests were treated as real-property interests for Section 1031. It does not approve every trust, fund, or offering. Your tax and legal team should review the interest you are considering. [14]
A DST can shift daily property work to a sponsor, but that also shifts decisions away from you. Review the properties, leases, debt, fees, reserves, and plan for sale. Ask what could reduce cash distributions and what options the sponsor would have in a difficult year.
The SEC warns that private placements may involve substantial risk, limited information, and restrictions on resale. Investors can lose their investment. Eligibility to invest is not a finding that the offering fits your needs. [15]
I would want you to understand the tradeoffs before deciding. Direct ownership may keep more control and work in your hands. A DST may reduce that work while limiting control and access to cash. The right choice depends on your circumstances, not which brochure has the more appealing number.
Generally, qualifying U.S. real estate held for investment or business can replace other qualifying U.S. real estate. The use and transaction must meet the rules, and state treatment should be checked separately. [1]
DOR lists 3.5% for 2026. That is a rate applied under the income-tax rules, not a percentage automatically owed on a property's sale price. Ask your CPA to calculate recognized gain and other relevant taxes. [3]
The state application says it is valid until the property transfers or its use changes. Ask the PVA about the new owner's application and the parcel's qualifying use and acreage. [6]
Do not assume so. Rural rules include permits, septic review, and limits on unhosted use. Check the current zoning rules and any recorded conservation easement before relying on rental income. [7] [11]
No. Use the map to guide a site review. A qualified professional may need more records, inspections, or tests to assess the actual conditions and proposed use. [12]
No. A private real estate investment carries risks, including loss and limited resale options. Read the offering documents and compare those risks with your income and cash-access needs. [15]
Educational information, not an offer or a personal tax, legal, or investment recommendation. Examples are hypothetical and omit stated adjustments. Tax treatment depends on your facts and current law. Review your transaction with your CPA, attorney, and qualified intermediary. Real estate investments can lose value and may be illiquid.
Enter your approved email to explore investments, save your shortlist, and keep learning.